The expenditure department of the finance ministry has sent
back India Post’s draft cabinet note seeking Rs.1,900 crore to set up a
commercial bank to another wing of the ministry and asked it to first seek the
approval of the expenditure finance committee (EFC). The entity is proposed to
be named Post Bank of India.
The postal department is among 26 applicants that sought banking licences from
the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on 1 July, part of the government’s initiative
to expand the Rs.77 trillion banking industry and widen access to financial
services among the 40% of the population that are yet not included in the
system.
“Since the proposal has financial consequences, we have told India Post to
first approach the expenditure finance committee with their proposal before
going for an inter-ministerial consultation on the matter,” said a finance
ministry official who didn’t want to be named.
A second finance ministry official confirmed this. He said the expenditure
finance committee was yet to receive the note from the postal department. He
said, however, that the committee was likely to clear the proposal once it’s
received.
“We cannot pre-empt how much money EFC will approve, however I am sure the
proposal makes sense because they have such a vast network which they should
utilize. The only thing is they have to develop the standards to meet the RBI
guidelines,” he added.
Approval of the expenditure finance committee, headed by the expenditure
secretary, is required for proposals involving spending of more than Rs.300
crore and the setting up of new autonomous organizations, regardless of the
amount.
The postal department, faced with the dwindling of its main business as more
people switch to electronic means of communication and courier companies, wants
to leverage its extensive reach across India by entering the banking business.
It’s currently involved in the financial industry to the extent that it runs
post-office savings schemes, besides collecting deposits for tax-free savings
programmes.
In its guidelines for new banking licences announced on 22 February, RBI
required applicants to prove their eligibility on several fronts—from promoter
holding to past experience to business plans. The minimum capital required by
applicants for licences is Rs.500 crore, and foreign shareholding in the new
banks is capped at 49% for the first five years.
The new banks have to be set up under a non-operative financial holding company
(NOFHC), RBI said. They also have to maintain a minimum capital adequacy
ratio—the ratio of capital to risk-weighted assets, a measure of financial
strength—of 13% for the first three years. New banks also need to list their
shares within three years of starting operations.
The finance ministry has been reluctant to allow India Post to enter the
commercial banking business.
In order to apply for a licence, the department of posts will have to create a
legal entity to segregate its banking and postal businesses, said a second
finance ministry official.
“It will have to be a government-owned company or a bank under a statute since
a government department cannot become a bank,” said the official, who didn’t
want to be identified.
“Added to that, the postal department has no experience when it comes to giving
credit. They have only been taking deposits till now. Sanctioning and
disbursing credit needs an entirely different aptitude,” the official said. “We
had conveyed our views to EY, when they had approached us on this issue,” he
added. EY (formerly Ernst & Young) is consultant to India Post’s bid for a
banking licence.
A third finance ministry official said it will be difficult for India Post to
get a banking licence from RBI since the guidelines call for a non-operative
financial holding company.
Besides that, although India Post boasts of a strong 150,000 branch network, a
majority of these may not get converted into bank branches in the event it gets
a licence, this official added.
“Expertise in (handling) National Savings Certificates will not be enough for
giving credit,” he added, making the point that the department has no
specialized experience in the business.
India Post had 154,822 branches across the country as of 31 March, the latest
data available, the largest for any postal department in the world, and close
to 90% of them—139,086—are in rural India. This is more than four times the
number of rural branches run by India’s banks.
RBI has clarified that the conditions it has set are merely the necessary ones
and that all applicants meeting them won’t be given a licence. The central bank
will screen the applications, refer them to an advisory committee and take a
final call on licences based on its recommendations.
If the focus is financial inclusion, the focus should be on looking for
solutions rather than raising barriers, said Ashvin Parekh, national leader,
global financial services at EY.
“Nobody is saying to convert the existing Post Office Savings Bank (POSB) into
a commercial bank. Post Bank of India has to be a subsidiary which needs to be
registered as a company and the government equity in this new entity could be
diluted,” he said. Through the POSB, India Post collects deposits starting as
low as Rs.20 with an annual interest rate of 4%.
Naina Lal Kidwai, country head of HSBC India and president of the Federation of
Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry lobby group, said in an interview that
though she is opposed to creating any more public sector banks, she supports
the idea of the Post Bank of India.
“The postal authority is a very interesting one because of its ability to
deliver cash where banks have never been able to reach. To create a post bank,
which many countries have done, is quite interesting. So for those exceptions,
we could and should look at giving (it a) banking licence,” she added.
However, Kidwai wants the government to reduce its share in the banking system
from 70% now to 30-50%, besides which she’d like to see consolidation of the
sector.
“We have to fund such banks through taxpayers’ money. These banks can rarely
raise money from the capital market. Some of those can actually be merged so
that we create fewer banks. So we should see a restructuring of our entire
banking sector,” she added.
